About Us
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
We at First Arkansas Insurance believe that the best way to serve our clients is to have a real understanding of their insurance needs. We listen to you, and offer realistic solutions. Please feel free to contact any of the following members of our staff, listed below by department.
Administration
Mike Carter, President
mcarter@fai-pb.com
David Beck, Vice President
dbeck@fai-pb.com
Andrea Johnson, Customer Service Manager
ajohnson@fai-pb.com
Accounting
Sharon Bates, Agency Accounting/HR Manager
sbates@fai-pb.com
Mary Beth Mitchell, Accounting
mmitchell@fai-pb.com
Back to the Menu
Claims
Jean Taylor, Claims Manager
jtaylor@fai-pb.com
Commercial Lines
Peggy Bennett, CSR/Account Manager
pbennett@fai-pb.com
Emily Kelley, Commercial Marketing Technology Director/Producer
ekelley@fai-pb.com
Evangeline Mosby, CSR/Account Manager
emosby@fai-pb.com
Cindy Nuckles, CSR/Account Manager
cnuckles@fai-pb.com
April O’Neal, CSR/Account Manager Home Builder Program
aoneal@fai-pb.com
Mike Sasser, Producer
msasser@fai-pb.com
Scott Scruggs, Producer
sscruggs@fai-pb.com
Matt Soto, Producer
msoto@fai-pb.com
Don Spharler, Producer
dspharler@fai-pb.com
Shirley Wilson, CSR/Account Manager
swilson@fai-pb.com
Employee Benefits
David McKinney, Producer(Group Health)
dmckinney@fai-pb.com
Ben Trevino, Employee Benefits Specialist
btrevino@fai-pb.com
Sandra McVay, CSR Employee Benefits
smcvay@fai-pb.com
Front Desk
Mickie Kelsey, Receptionist
mkelsey@fai-pb.com
Personal Lines
Carolyn Joe, CSR/Account Manager
cjoe@fai-pb.com
Elizabeth Matthews, CSR/Account Manager
ematthews@fai-pb.com
Pine Bluff National Bank (Jefferson Insurance & Financial Services)
Stacy Haynes, Producer
(870) 540-4919
shaynes@fai-pb.com
First Arkansas Insurance, Northwest Arkansas
Tracy Stephens, President
One West Mountain Street
Fayetteville, AR 72701
479-251-7515
tstephens@fai-nwa.com









